Governance Structure Choices in Supply Chain Management Evidence from Spanish and Chinese Pork Chain Cases

The author participated in the 6 th EU Framework Project ―Q-pork Chains (FP6-036245-2)‖ from 2007 to 2009. With understanding of work reports from China and other countries, it is found that compared with other countries, China has great problems in pork quality and safety. By comparing the pork chain management between China and Spain, It is found that the difference in governance structure is one of the main differences in pork chain management between Spain and China. In China, spot-market relationship still dominates governance structure of pork chain, especially between the numerous house-hold pig holders and the great number of small slaughters. While in Spain, chain agents commonly apply cooperatives or integrations to cooperate. It also has been proven by recent studies, that in quality management at the chain level that supply chain integration has a direct effect on quality management practices (Han, 2010). Therefore, the author started to investigate the governance structure choices in supply chain management. And it has been set as the first research objective, which is to explain the governance structure choices process and the influencing factors in supply chain management, analyzing the pork chains cases in Spain and in China. During the further investigation, the author noticed the international trade of pork between Spain and China is not smooth since the signature of bi-lateral agreement on pork trade in 2007. Thus, another objective of the research is to find and solve the problems exist in the international pork chain between Spain and China. For the first objective, to explain the governance structure choices in supply chain management, the thesis conducts research in three main sections. 10 First of all, the thesis gives a literature overview in chapter two on Supply Chain Management (SCM), agri-food chain management and pork chain management. It concludes that SCM is a systems approach to view the supply chains as a whole, and to manage the total flow of goods inventory from the supplier to the ultimate customer. It includes the bi-directional flow of products (materials and services) and information, and the associated managerial and operational activities. And it also is a customer focus to create unique and individual source of customer value with an appropriate use of resources, leading to customer satisfaction and building competitive chain advantages. Agri-food chain management and pork chain management are applications of SCM in agri-food sector and pork sector respectively. Then, the research gives a comparative study in chapter three in the pork chain and pork chain management between Spain and China. Many differences are found, while the main difference is governance structure in pork chain management. Furthermore, the author gives an empirical study on governance structure choice in chapter five. It is concluded that governance structure of supply chain consists of a collection of rules/institutions/constraints structuring the transactions between the various stakeholders. Based on the overview on literatures closely related with governance structure, such as transaction cost economics, transaction value analysis and resource-based view theories, seven hypotheses are proposed, which are: Hypothesis 1: Transaction cost has positive relationship with governance structure choice Hypothesis 2: Uncertainty has positive relationship with transaction cost; higher uncertainty exerts high transaction cost Hypothesis 3: The relationship between asset specificity and transaction cost is positive Hypothesis 4: Collaboration advantages and governance structure choice have positive relationship11 Hypothesis 5: Willingness to collaborate has positive relationship with collaboration advantages Hypothesis 6: Capability to collaborate has positive relationship with collaboration advantages Hypothesis 7: Uncertainty has negative effect on collaboration advantages It is noted that as transaction cost value is negative, the transaction cost mentioned in the hypotheses is its absolute value. To test the seven hypotheses, Structural Equation Model (SEM) is applied and data collected from 350 pork slaughtering and processing companies in Jiangsu, Shandong and Henan Provinces in China is used. Based on the empirical SEM model and its results, the seven hypotheses are proved. The author generates several conclusions accordingly. It is found that the governance structure choice of the chain not only depends on transaction cost, it also depends on collaboration advantages. Exchange partners establish more stable and more intense relationship to reduce transaction cost and to maximize collaboration advantages. ―Collaboration advantages‖ in this thesis is defined as the joint value achieved through transaction (mutual activities) of agents in supply chains. This value forms as improvements, mainly in mutual logistics systems, cash response, information exchange, technological improvements and innovative improvements and quality management improvements, etc. Governance structure choice is jointly decided by transaction cost and collaboration advantages. Chain agents take different governance structures to coordinate in order to decrease their transaction cost and to increase their collaboration advantages. In China´s pork chain case, spot market relationship dominates the governance structure among the numerous backyard pig farmer and small family slaughterhouse 12 as they are connected by acquaintance relationship and the transaction cost in turn is low. Their relationship is reliable as they know each other in the neighborhood; as a result, spot market relationship is suitable for their exchange. However, the transaction between large-scale slaughtering and processing industries and small-scale pig producers is becoming difficult. The information hold back behavior and hold-up behavior of small-scale pig producers increase transaction cost between them and large-scale slaughtering and processing industries. Thus, through the more intense and stable relationship between processing industries and pig producers, processing industries reduce the transaction cost and improve the collaboration advantages with their chain partners, in which quality and safety collaboration advantages be increased, meaning that processing industries are able to provide consumers products with better quality and higher safety. It is also drawn that transaction cost is influenced mainly by uncertainty and asset specificity, which is in line with new institutional economics theories developed by Williamson O. E. In China´s pork chain case, behavioral uncertainty is created by the hold-up behaviors of great numbers of small pig producers, while big slaughtering and processing industries having strong asset specificity. On the other hand, ―collaboration advantages‖ is influenced by chain agents´ willingness to collaborate and chain agents´ capabilities to cooperate. With the fast growth of big scale slaughtering and processing industries, they are more willing to know and make effort to cooperate with their chain members, and they are more capable to create joint value together with other chain agents. Therefore, they are now the main chain agents who drive more intense and stable governance structure in China‘s pork chain. For the other objective, to find and solve the problems in the international pork chain between Spain and China, the research gives an analysis in chapter four on the 13 international pork chain. This study gives explanations why the international trade of pork between Spain and China is not sufficient from the chain perspective. It is found that the first obstacle is the high quality and safety requirement set by Chinese government. It makes the Spanish companies difficult to get authorities to export. Other aspects, such as Spanish pork is not competitive in price compared with other countries such as Denmark, United States, Canada, etc., Chinese consumers do not have sufficient information on Spanish pork products, are also important reasons that Spain does not export great quantity of pork products to China. It is concluded that China´s government has too much concern on the quality and safety requirements to Spanish pork products, which makes trade difficult to complete. The two countries need to establish a more stable and intense trade relationship. They also should make the information exchange sufficient and efficient and try to break trade barriers. Spanish companies should consider proper price strategies to win the Chinese pork market

Problemática estructural y de funcionamiento de la cadena de valor del jamón ibérico de bellota: el caso de Guijuelo en España

El sector porcino ibérico es un sector típicamente español. La imagen que asocia el consumidor a los productos ibéricos es la correspondiente a los productos elaborados a partir de cerdos ibéricos en explotaciones extensivas, (dehesas), y cebados en montanera. Sin embargo, según los datos publicados por el Ministerio de Agricultura, Alimentación y Medio Ambiente, más de un 70 por ciento de los cerdos ibéricos que se producen en España son criados en granjas intensivas. El sector porcino ibérico está en pleno proceso de cambio, tanto por las variaciones que se derivan de la crisis que sufre el sector, como por las modificaciones que se esperan en la norma de calidad, recientemente acordadas. En este entorno en el que existe una reducción importante de los márgenes comerciales en todos los eslabones de la cadena de valor del jamón ibérico de bellota, adquiere importancia el estudio de su estructura y funcionamiento, la determinación de los aspectos que mejoran la eficiencia económica a lo largo de la misma y su concordancia a lo largo de ella. Así mismo, un sector de los consumidores comienza a buscar productos de calidad, se interesa por productos con determinados etiquetados que garantizan la calidad o unas determinadas prácticas de producción y elaboración, como sucede con los productos ecológicos. Existen numerosos estudios sobre distintos aspectos del sector porcino ibérico, realizados por distintas instituciones, como universidades, instituciones privadas y proyectos europeos. En general, se centran en la mejora de la producción de los cerdos ibéricos o en la mejora de la elaboración de los jamones. La novedad de la investigación realizada en la presente Tesis Doctoral reside en el estudio de los aspectos que determinan la mayor eficiencia económica de la cadena de valor del jamón ibérico de bellota de la denominación de origen de Guijuelo, y en las características que aporta al jamón ibérico de bellota la producción ecológica frente a la convencional. Resumen Los objetivos planteados en esta investigación son la mejora de la cadena de valor del jamón ibérico de bellota de la denominación de origen de Guijuelo, mediante el estudio de la problemática estructural y de funcionamiento de la misma. Como objetivos específicos se proponen la mejora de la eficiencia económica en las relaciones comerciales entre los distintos eslabones de la cadena de valor, y el impulso de la oferta de los productos ecológicos de ibérico, mediante el estudio comparativo de las producciones convencionales y ecológicas. Para alcanzar estos objetivos la metodología utilizada es la cadena de valor agroalimentaria, utilizando como herramientas de análisis el método Delphi y la realización de un análisis DAFO del sector porcino ibérico. Las fuentes de información primarias utilizadas proceden por una parte de la colaboración realizada en el proyecto europeo Q-Porkchains, coordinado por el Dr. Jacques H. Trienekens, y por otra parte de los cuestionarios especialmente diseñados para el análisis Delphi realizado. Las fuentes de información secundarias proceden de artículos académicos publicados, de artículos de revistas especializadas en el sector y de informes y estadísticas publicados por el Ministerio de Agricultura, Alimentación y Medio Ambiente. Las conclusiones de la investigación son las siguientes. Las relaciones comerciales de la cadena de valor estudiada están gestionadas, ya que se otorga gran valor a las relaciones comerciales basadas en la confianza, tanto en el aprovisionamiento de productos como en la venta de los mismos en cada eslabón. Sin embargo, no se gestiona adecuadamente la gama de productos que se oferta a lo largo de la cadena de valor, puesto que los eslabones de la misma obtienen diferente eficiencia económica para el mismo producto. Por otra parte, aunque la denominación de origen de Guijuelo es una marca conocida por el consumidor, el esfuerzo por tener una marca colectiva de calidad no ha sido totalmente satisfactorio, en especial para el eslabón de la distribución. Por esta razón, es importante resaltar que es recomendable la creación de una marca propia que cuide la calidad con especial atención, modificando incluso las empresas integrantes de la cadena de valor si el objetivo de calidad no coincide. Es importante garantizar la calidad del producto al consumidor, mediante la trasmisión la información generada por los informes de inspección y certificación realizados por las entidades correspondientes en relación a la norma de calidad de los productos de cerdo ibérico y por el Consejo Regulador de Guijuelo. Se requiere un estudio detallado de los posibles nichos de mercado para llegar a los clientes que buscan un producto de calidad diferenciada como es el jamón ibérico de denominación de origen de Guijuelo. Dentro de los posibles clientes debe tenerse en consideración al colectivo de personas alérgicas, ya que no se encuentran con facilidad en el mercado productos cárnicos de cerdo libres de alérgenos. Por último, la innovación es muy importante en este sector, y pueden ofertarse nuevos productos que ayuden al acortamiento de la cadena de valor, como podría ser la carne fresca de cerdo ibérico de bellota. La producción ecológica de porcino ibérico, en la actualidad no es significativa. El manejo que se realiza de los cerdos ibéricos convencionales de bellota es muy similar al manejo que se realiza de los cerdos ecológicos, salvo en la alimentación que reciben los cerdos ibéricos antes del cebo en montanera y en los medicamentos permitidos en ambas producciones. La producción de porcino ecológico de bellota puede ser interesante para la exportación. Los jamones ibéricos de bellota dispondrían de un sello que garantiza un manejo tradicional –como se realiza en muchas explotaciones extensivas de cerdos ibéricos de bellota-, y que es apreciado por los consumidores de otros países, dispuestos a pagar por productos de calidad diferenciada. Este tipo de producción quizá podría solventar la limitación al ámbito nacional de la norma de calidad de los productos de cerdo ibérico. La falta de claridad y unanimidad en el sector sobre la calidad de los productos de ibéricos que se percibe en los cambios previstos en la legislación, y el interés del eslabón de la industria elaboradora de jamones en calidades no ligadas a producciones extensivas sino intensivas, por su mayor volumen de ventas y sus mejores rendimientos, mueven a los productores de “ibérico puro de bellota” a desmarcarse del sector “ibérico”, donde el peso del producto ibérico cruzado de pienso tiene mucho peso en las decisiones que se toman. The Iberian pork industry is a typically Spanish industry. The associated image by the consumer to these products corresponds to products made from Iberian pigs in extensive farms (meadows), and fattened in open range. However, according to data released by the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Environment, more than 70 percent of the Iberian pigs produced in Spain are raised on factory farms. The Iberian pork industry is in process of change, both by modifications resulting from the crisis in the sector, and the expected ones in the quality standard, recently agreed. In this environment where there is a significant reduction in trade margins in all links of the value chain of Iberian ham, becomes important to study its structure and operation, identifying the aspects that improve economic efficiency along the value chain and their concordance along it. Likewise, part of the consumers begins searching for quality products, they are interested in certain products that guarantee some sort of quality or production and processing practices, like organic products. There are several studies on various aspects of the Iberian pork industry, made by different institutions, such as universities, private institutions and some European projects. In general, their goal is focused on improving the Iberian hog production or on improving the elaboration of hams. The novelty of the research conducted in this PhD thesis lies in the study of the aspects that determine the economic efficiency of the value chain of Iberian ham from Guijuelo designation of origin, and the comparison between the features that organic or conventional production of Iberian ham brings to it. The objectives propound in this research are the improvement of the value chain of Iberian ham from Guijuelo designation of origin, through the study of its structural and operational problematic. The proposed specific objectives are the improvement of the economic efficiency Resumen in trade relations between the different links in the value chain, and the promotion of the supply of Iberian organic pork products, through the comparative study of conventional and organic productions. In order to achieve these objectives, the used methodology is the agrifood value chain, using as analysis tools the Delphi method, and a SWOT analysis of the Iberian pork industry. The primary sources of information come partly from the collaboration in the European project Q-Porkchains, coordinated by Dr. Jacques Trienekens, and partly from the questionnaires specially designed for the Delphi analysis performed. The secondary sources come from published academic papers, specialized journal articles and reports published by the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Environment. The research conclusions are as follows. Trade relations in the studied value chain are managed, as it is granted a great value to business relationships based on trust, both in the supply of products and in the sale in each link. However, the portfolio that is offered throughout the value chain is not properly managed, since the economic efficiency obtained for the same product is different in each link. Moreover, although the designation of origin of Guijuelo is a well-known brand, the effort made to acquire a collective quality trademark has not been entirely satisfactory, especially in the distribution link. Due to it, it is important to highlight that it is recommended to create a brand focused on quality, and indeed to change the firms integrating the vale chain, if the goal is not shared by all the companies. It is essential to ensure the quality of the product to the consumer, through the transmission of the available information related to the quality standard of Iberian pork products and of the Guijuelo Regulating Council. A detailed study of potential niche markets is required, in order to reach customers looking for a differentiated quality product as Iberian ham of Guijuelo designation of origin. It should be taken into consideration the group of allergy sufferers as potential customers, as they do not easily find pork products in the market free of allergens. Innovation is very important in this industry, and new products could be commercialized that help to shorten the value chain, as fresh acorn Iberian pork. Nowadays, the organic production of Iberian pork products is not significant. The operation is very similar in both conventional and organic production of Iberian pork products, except in the food received by Iberian hogs and the sort of medicinal treatments allowed in each production. The organic acorn Iberian pork production could be interesting for export. Acorn Iberian hams would have a well-known hallmark, which guarantees a traditional production, -as it is done in many extensive holdings of Iberian acorn-pigs-, and that is appreciated by consumers in other countries This niche of consumers could pay for differentiated quality products. Perhaps, this sort of production could solve the limitation to national scope of the quality standard of Iberian pork products. The lack of clarity and unanimity in the industry on the quality of Iberian pork products has been perceived in the agreed changes of the legislation as well as the interest of the processing industry in hams of quality categories which are not linked to extensive but intensive productions, due to their higher sales volume and better yields. This situation pushed "acorn pure Iberian " pigs farmers to split from the Iberian industry, where the importance of cross Iberian pig from intensive farms is growing so high that they can influence the negotiations and decisions taken inside and outside the industry.

Indicators of sustainability of agriculture and livestock in Spain - Indicadores de sostenibilidad de la agricultura y ganadería española

Sustainability is an adjective used to characterize agriculture according to the degree of fulfillment of goals. Those goals are related to agro-ecological, environmental and socio-economic dimensions. Sustainability is a dynamic and temporal character. In absolute terms there is not an ending value because it changes as its dimensions make it. Spain is one of the main agricultural countries of the European Union both in terms of crop land and value of productions. The object of this study is to present a methodology of sustainability account to be incorporated into national statistical and to assess their performance in the course of the years. For that reason the data sources used have been the statistics of the Department of Agriculture and from others database. We presented a set of indicators of sustainability and its evaluation in a time series of at least 30 years. The trend analysis offers the evolution of the numerical values of the indicators in terms of efficiency, physical units used for a unit of product or its value in euros. The analyzed crops have been: wheat, barley, maize, sunflower, sugar beet, wine grape, olive oil, citrus, melon and tomato. Physical indicators were: land, water, energy, erosion, soil organic matter, and carbon balance; socio-economic indicators were: agricultural final production, prices, income, employment and use of fertilizers. In general, all crops increased their productive efficiency, higher in irrigated than on dry land. Spanish agricultural carbon sequestration capacity has multiplied by five in the last seventy years, as a result of the increase in the productivity of crops, in terms of total biomass and the modification of the soil management techniques. Livestock sector presents data of pork, broilers and laying hen. Those showed an improvement in efficiency and economic indicators. Overall we can say that Spanish agriculture and livestock subsector have a tendency towards sustainability, being its main threats extreme meteorological factors and the instability of todays markets.